Skip to content 
I often get peppered with questions about remote collars for pups. You know, things like “Hey, is my little buddy too young for an e-collar?” or “Can I pop one of those remote collars on my 4-month-old furball?”
The general thumb rule among most dog trainers is to wait until they hit the six-month mark. Now, from what I’ve seen in my own practice, I’m leaning more toward the 9-month age. And here’s why:
By the time they’re 9 months, most pups have grown enough to be comfy with the feel of a remote collar.
Around this age, dogs are more mentally mature. They can understand what that little buzz or beep from the collar means much better.
Ideally, you want your dog to know basic commands before introducing a remote collar. By 9 months, they’ve usually got the basics down pat.
However, starting e-collar training with your dog is a big decision, and it’s not just about how old your dog is. Many people think the age of the dog is the most important thing, but there’s more to it than that.
Here, I’ll talk about when the right time is to start using an e-collar with your dog. You’ll know exactly what age is best for puppies to start this kind of training and when a dog is old enough for a shock collar.
I’ll also give you tips on how to use an e-collar safely with puppies. So, Let’s dive into this hot topic one step at a time.
What Age Is Appropriate for Training a Dog With an E-Collar?
I typically start training dogs with a remote collar at 9 months, not because other ages are wrong, but because this is when dogs start testing limits as they transition to adulthood. It’s a period when they seek more freedom, which remote collar training can facilitate.
Most Pet Parents often reach this stage feeling overwhelmed, realizing their previous training methods aren’t working. Puppies usually undergo initial training like puppy socials and basic obedience classes, often at big-box pet stores that promote various training aids. However, many dogs still exhibit behavioral issues after months of such training. So, here’s all that you need to know:
How to Condition Your Dog for E-Collar Training
E-collar training is based on two fundamental principles: teaching your dog the desired behavior and reinforcing this behavior using the collar.
The first step, known as collar-conditioning, involves clearly showing your dog what is expected before using the collar. This helps avoid confusion and fear, as the dog understands the link between its behavior and the collar’s stimulation.
Before beginning training, it’s beneficial to let your dog get accustomed to wearing the new collar without activating it. This period could range from five days to a month. This approach has two key advantages:
Firstly, the dog becomes comfortable with the collar as part of its daily routine; secondly, it reduces the likelihood of the dog becoming ‘collar wise,’ which means it will respond better to training, with or without the collar.
Early Training Stages: 3-6+ Months with Prong Collar
Moreover, I prefer to start young puppies (aged 3-6+ months, varying with breed and temperament) with a prong collar. This early stage involves what I call pre-conditioning for the remote collar, simultaneously continuing with the food-based training already in progress.
The initial step involves introducing the concept of pressure: understanding its application and how the puppy can control its presence and absence. This concept is not only vital for prong collar training but also forms the basis for transitioning to e-collar training.
The prong collar serves to lay the groundwork that the remote collar will later enhance. It helps fine-tune basic commands like heel and recall learned through food rewards and addresses some unwanted behaviors.
Transitioning from Prong to Remote Collar
Once the puppy is accustomed to the prong collar, transitioning to the remote collar becomes smoother. This shift allows for more reliable training outcomes, thereby granting the dog greater freedom.
This method, involving a progression from prong to remote collar, is one of several approaches. It’s important to note that while a prong collar can be beneficial, it isn’t mandatory for starting e-collar training with puppies.
Mental Readiness for Training Collars
Most importantly, when introducing a dog training collar, it’s crucial to assess whether your dog is mentally developed enough to understand the reason behind corrections. This is true for all types of training collars, including citronella spray and electronic collars. It’s often argued that citronella collars are more suitable for younger dogs. However, training will be ineffective if the dog cannot mentally connect its behavior with the correction it receives.
Puppies under 6 months of age should not be subjected to e-collar training. At this young age, they may not be fully capable of understanding or coping with various types of stimulation provided by e-collars.
Types of E-Collar Stimulation and Their Appropriateness:
- Shock Stimulation: Suitable for more aggressive or older dogs. Modern e-collars offer varying levels of shock stimulation to tailor to your dog’s tolerance and needs.
- Vibration Stimulation: Ideal for younger, timid dogs.
- Tone Stimulation: Best for extremely timid puppies or very young dogs.
- Citronella Spray Collars: Effective for barking issues. Available in automatic and remote-controlled versions, with the former being more suitable for addressing barking and the latter for a more controlled training approach.
The goal is to choose a level of stimulation that gets your dog’s attention without causing pain or fear. Signs like ear twitching or head turning indicate an appropriate level, while whining or tail tucking suggests the stimulation is too strong. Testing the collar on your hand can help gauge the intensity of the vibration.
Pro Tips:
- Training your dog to associate the beep or tone with the impending negative stimulus can eventually allow you to control undesired behaviors with just the sound, reducing the need for physical stimulation.
- Conceal the remote control to prevent your dog from associating it with negative experiences. This helps in focusing the training on the behavior rather than the device, preventing potential fear or aggression towards the remote.
Role of Dog’s Behavior in Training With E-Collar
Observing your dog’s temperament is vital before starting e-collar training. Dogs with a milder disposition might react negatively to early introduction of e-collars, potentially causing lasting impacts on their behavior and personality.
Conversely, dogs with aggressive tendencies require careful handling during e-collar training to manage their challenging behavior without exacerbating their aggression.
You can often gauge your dog’s readiness for collar training by observing its reactions to everyday situations. For instance, if your dog starts to avoid places where it had an unpleasant experience or becomes cautious in certain situations, it shows an ability to learn from experiences. Key questions to consider include:
- Can your dog understand the link between its behavior and the corrections from the collar?
- What is the appropriate correction level for your dog? It’s important to find a balance to avoid overstressing the dog, especially younger ones. Modern dog training collars offer adjustable correction levels to suit your dog’s age and temperament.
Here’s a table summarizing the arguments for and against the use of E-Collars in dog training:
| Arguments Favoring E-Collar Use | Arguments Against Using E-Collars in Dog Training |
| E-collars are seen as another form of negative reinforcement, akin to other dog training methods. The emphasis is on their responsible use. | E-collars can cause discomfort or pain, leading to stress and anxiety in dogs. They may also increase aggressive behaviors in some dogs. |
| Modern e-collars are much more advanced, with up to 65 levels of stimulation. This helps in adjusting the collar to a level that is effective but not painful, suited to different dog sizes and sensitivities. | E-collars are often seen as less reliable for dog training, with negative reinforcement being less effective than positive reinforcement methods for long-term behavioral change. |
| Some dogs respond better to e-collar stimulation than to other forms of negative reinforcement. The immediate and distinct stimulus from e-collars can be more efficient in training for certain behaviors. | E-collars are sometimes chosen for convenience, offering a quicker but less effective training method. This approach is seen as bypassing more rewarding and humane training methods. |
Final Thoughts!
It’s crucial to understand that e-collars should not be the primary method of training. Instead, they should complement other, more positive training techniques. The emphasis in dog training should be on positive reinforcement, rewarding good behavior rather than solely focusing on correcting the undesirable ones.
Evidence strongly suggests that positive reinforcement is more effective in training dogs. This involves rewarding your dog for desirable behaviors, using verbal praise, and teaching commands like “no” in a non-punitive way.
E-collars might only be necessary for specific and persistent issues, such as preventing a dog from running into the street, excessive barking, jumping on people, biting, leash aggression, or other challenging behaviors.
This article aimed to clarify when it’s appropriate to introduce an e-collar to your dog. Remember, the focus should always be on humane and responsible use. If you have questions or need more advice, feel free to get in touch!
